I recently had a debate with a couple of friends regarding the pace of political change back home in Malaysia, especially with regards to the stated aim of the opposition to topple the ruling coalition and form a government.
It has always been my point of view that change for the sake of change is both naive and a non-starter, and would only lead to chaos both at a political and social level. When you cut off the head of an animal, the body eventually withers and dies. But when you cut off the head of a political entity, the leftovers become separate beings (much like the heads of a hydra), each acting in a chaotic, potentially dangerous and unstable manner.
It is therefore pertinent to come up with a roadmap or even a skeleton of a guideline to help the transition of power, not just for the holders of these newly-acquired powers, but for the rakyat, whose support is needed if one is to throw out the mandate given to Barisan Nasional.
One only needs to compare the situation to the other scion of change, Barack Obama, over at the States and how he has made a clear-cut indication on the direction that he will be heading towards. Granted, we are all bound to be disappointed at some stage or another as he has been elevated to messianic levels, but at least we have an idea on the path that he will take. This has not been the case for the opposition in Malaysia, and that was the bone of contention in our little debate.
It has been pointed out to me that it would be politically naive for the opposition to not grab the opportunity to establish a government at the current climate, i.e. one has to strike whilst the iron is hot. It might be true with regards to holding onto power in the short run, but if they were to cling onto power with the barest of grips, and end up performing badly due to mismanagement and the lack of cohesive planning, then it would be back to the drawing board for the next election campaign. Surely the recipe for long-term success is to build upon what they already have and prove to the sceptics that they can walk the talk.
I am glad to say that this has already begun to a certain degree e.g. with Anwar stating that he is in no hurry to form a government (after all, what use would a single-digit majority be?) and with the presentation of an alternative budget.
And whilst the states of Kedah and Penang continue to bicker and make a mockery of their partnership, it is quite heartening to see the changes that are being attempted at the state of Selangor (and no, this is not me being biased because of
Budu).
The most striking feature of the administration so far is the fact that it has not shied away from promoting the concept of meritocracy, even at the expense of the popular vote amongst certain sectors of the Malay population. After the UiTM saga, a similar backlash is seen with the announcement by the Chief Minister that he intends to appoint a Chinese lady to temporarily head the PKNS.
Rather unsurprisingly, this move has come up with resistance from a number of Malay individuals within the State government, with the excuse that the PKNS was established to protect Malay interests. These individuals have obviously chosen to rewrite history and ignore the fact that the state body was created to help develop the state from a socio-economic point of view - an aim that would be applicable to all, regardless of one’s skin colour or ethnicity. The fact that a 20-odd-year veteran of the body was appointed to lead it should be met with aplomb, not whinged about.
Opposition was also voiced by the PAS element within the state government, which once again, is rather unsurprising. It merely serves to highlight the fact that PAS has yet to change its spots, and for all its talk about equal rights and the abolishment of anti-Islamic policies, it has not actually moved away from its parochial mentality, and shows no signs of doing so anytime soon.
It is almost tiresome to talk about the need to move away from a mentality where protectionism is a given and one need not strive for a higher strata in order to be rewarded. Beneficial change will not come overnight though, and it will take small, concrete steps such as these to open up the mental landscape of the rakyat at large.
I still have my doubts about PAS though, and I will greet the day that PKR and PAS cease becoming bedmates with great alacrity.